
We all know that baseball’s a funny game when it comes to recognizing talent (Derek Jeter’s Gold Glove? Dustin Pedroia’s MVP?) and a lot of the time, we fail to see that the All-Star team is actually a criminal mis-representation of who should actually be there. Not to say that all of these guys on this list are All-Stars, but many of them deserve much more credit than they deserve.
SP: R.A. Dickey, New York Mets.
He’s not a fluke, he’s not a one-hit wonder, Dickey is the only effective knuckleballer in the league and was a huge reason the Mets stayed in contention for so long. ERA and wins aren’t great measuring sticks, but he’s 11-9 with a 2.86 this year.
Honorable Mention: Mat Latos, San Diego Padres, Jered Weaver, Los Angeles Angels
RP: Koji Uehara, Baltimore Orioles.
He’s quietly having a fantastic year in Baltimore. Since assuming the unofficial closer role in the Oriole ‘pen, he’s shut down nearly everyone. Only two blown saves all year (both were to the Yankees). He owns an absurd K/BB ratio of 52/5.
Honorable Mention: Tyler Clippard, Washington Nationals
C: Miguel Montero, Arizona Diamondbacks
Arizona’s 26 year old backstop played his first full season in 2009 and was one of the best hitting catchers in the league batting .294 with 16 homers replacing Chad Tracy as their everyday catcher. His power and production have dropped off slightly this year, but in Arizona’s putrid offense, is that really surprising?
Honorable Mention: Kurt Suzuki
1B: Billy Butler, Kansas City Royals
Despite grounding into a lot of double plays, Butler has a career high OPS of .859, a career high OBP of .389, and a career high BA of .319. Oh, and the folks he’s had for lineup “protection” are Alex Gordon and Yuniesky Betancourt.
Honorable Mention: Kendry Morales, Los Angeles Angels
2B: Ian Kinsler, Texas Rangers
He wasn’t healthy this year and that caused his performance to suffer, but last year he was a force. He’s had both a 20/20 and a 30/30 season and he’s only 28. He’s quickly emerged as one of the best power-hitting second basemen in the league, but is still playing in the shadow of Dustin Pedroia for some reason.
Honorable Mention: Chase Utley (really!)
SS: Starlin Castro, Chicago Cubs
Had this been a regular season for the Cubs, the media storm would be all over this guy and he’d probably be on the overrated list. But it’s not and the Cubs are wallowing in the cellar of the worst division in baseball, so no one talks about him. The only news you ever hear about him is that he had six RBIs in his Major League debut this year, but he’s batting a robust .300 and has just as many walks as strikeouts. Plus, he’s played pretty well with the glove this year too.
Honorable Mention: Brendan Ryan, St. Louis Cardinals
3B: Ryan Zimmerman, Washington Nationals
Zimmerman is one of the best players in the game. Period. End of story. He’s one of the best defensive talents I’ve ever seen, and he also had big year at the plate for one of the worst teams in baseball. There’s little more that needs to be said, but I think it’s easy to say that if he even played for an average team, he’d be getting MVP votes left and right.
Honorable Mention: Michael Young, Texas Rangers
OF: Nick Markakis, Baltimore Orioles
He probably has the best arm in the majors and consistently leads the league in outfield assists. He’s one of the best contact hitters in the game today and although his power-stroke has diminished, Markakis still sits near the top of the league in doubles and became just the third player in Major League history to hit 43 doubles in four straight years.
Honorable Mention: Marlon Byrd, Chicago Cubs
Shin-Soo Choo, Cleveland Indians
Another one of those guys that has a great all around game, but plays in a blacked out baseball market that has fallen into irrelevancy, Choo hits for power, hits for contact, and is the best player the Indians have right now. Since Grady Sizemore has slipped into irrelevancy, Choo has broken through as the clubs offensive leader.
Honorable Mention: Luke Scott, Baltimore Orioles
Franklin Gutierrez, Seattle Mariners
He’s got to be the best defensive center-fielder in the MLB. Part of the “Death to Flying Things” outfield along with Ichiro and Russel “The Mussel” Branyan, he covers so much ground and has so much natural ability that it’s almost impossible to sneak one in there. He’s not great at the dish, but his defense makes up for it ten-fold. Besides, he can also swipe bases nabbing 25 in 2010.
Honorable Mentions: Colby Rasmus, St. Louis Cardinals